HEAD TO HEAD
Ruoxi Qiu: canopy-jev and Maziyar Panahi: modernjev-decide, compared on what they decide, where they run, what they cost and what their publishers report.
| Property | camellia86/canopy-jev | maziyar-panahi/modernjev-decide |
|---|---|---|
| Summary | Ruoxi Qiu's decision adapter for a frozen Qwen3.8-27B: a 6.3M-parameter LoRA on the last four text layers plus a numerical prior. One shared state feeds isolated question branches; each Choice, Noul or Score question returns probabilities with no generated tokens. | A 149.6M ModernBERT-base cross-encoder with a scalar head that picks an agent's next action or tool from labels and descriptions you supply. Each option is scored against the state and a softmax ranks the set; no text is generated. Experimental preview, not calibrated. |
| Decides | choice, noul, score | choice, rank, route |
| Architecture | canopy-jev | modernjev |
| Fine-tuned from | qwen/qwen3.8-27b | answerdotai/modernbert-base |
| License | apache-2.0 | apache-2.0 |
| Availability | Open weights | Open weights |
| Hosted by | — | — |
| Input price | — | — |
| Decision accuracy | 87.4% | 73.4% |
| Calibration error | — | — |
| Valid action rate | — | — |
| Median latency | — | — |
| p95 latency | — | — |
| Evaluation suite | JevBench public set (231 items; 202 correct), the maker's own fresh zero-shot run with the upstream scorer | AgentToolDecisions-180K held-out test, next action type (1,158 decisions, 3 choices; the maker's split) |
| Latest version | 0.1.0 | 2026.09 |
| Variants | LICENSE, NOTICE, artifacts, licenses | — |
| Size of latest version | 24.1 MB | 574.1 MB |
| Files | 11 | 5 |
| Downloads | 0 | 0 |
| Stars | 0 | 0 |
| Tags | system-one, qwen, lora, adapter, shared-state, 27b | system-one, encoder, modernbert, cross-encoder, tool-routing, preview, 149.6m |
| Updated | Oct 7, 2026 | Oct 7, 2026 |
Figures are from each model’s manifest; accuracy and latency are what the publishers report, on their own suites and hardware. Add a third model.
canopy-jev is from Ruoxi Qiu and modernjev-decide from Maziyar Panahi. Both have open weights you can download and run. Both answer choice questions. Only canopy-jev answers noul and score. Only modernjev-decide answers rank and route. modernjev-decide is the smaller model, at 150M parameters to 27B.
They report on different suites — canopy-jev 87.4% on JevBench public set (231 items; 202 correct), the maker's own fresh zero-shot run with the upstream scorer, modernjev-decide 73.4% on AgentToolDecisions-180K held-out test, next action type (1,158 decisions, 3 choices; the maker's split) — so the numbers do not rank them. Test both on your own labelled examples.
canopy-jev: Free (open weights). modernjev-decide: Free (open weights). Open weights cost nothing per call beyond your own hardware.
Yes, both: systemone pull camellia86/canopy-jev and systemone pull maziyar-panahi/modernjev-decide download the weights.